(reposted from The Huffington Post)
The common good, by definition, requires each of us to fulfill our public responsibilities. Not just some of us. And not just government.
Finance Minister Joe Oliver announced that eight of Canadian largest banks would voluntarily introduce low-cost and no-fee bank accounts to some low-income Canadians.
Yet the majority of low-income Canadians were excluded. The accounts, not to be implemented until 2015, are only for low-income seniors and youth.
These banks should extend this benefit to the large number of Canadians between the ages of 18 and 65 who are also currently living in poverty. It is critical that services for low-income people are universal and not create divisions between the deserving and the un-deserving poor.
While recent policies have reduced poverty among children and seniors, income supports for working-age individuals have been cut back. Today there are over a million single working-age Canadians living in poverty. And many more low-income families. Most within these two groups won’t benefit from this service, yet together they make up about 90% of people living in poverty.
This move represents an important recognition by both the Minister of Finance and the Canadian banking community of the needs of people living in poverty. In a letter to the CEOs of these eight banks, Citizens for Public Justice’s (CPJ) Board Chair, Will Postma, thanked the banks for taking this step to, “deliver accessible services for those Canadians for whom every dollar counts.” But Postma also pointed to the need to, “widen the net of benefit to include the many more Canadians who are also low-income.”
These kinds of voluntary actions on the part of the private sector are never a replacement for the key role government plays. As Canada Without Poverty points out, “it will be difficult to effectively implement these changes without concrete guidelines and bank policies in place.” Good government should ensure access to public services that benefit all while enabling the private sector to do their part in meeting community needs.
So let’s care for the poor and marginalized in a way that all, not just some, can live with dignity. It is, after all, a central responsibility of our individual and corporate citizenship.
Letter
To:
Gordon Nixon, CEO, Royal Bank of Canada
ED Clark, CEO, TD Bank Group
Bill Downe, CEO, Bank of Montreal
Brian Porter, CEO, Scotiabank
Gerald T. McCaughey, CEO, CIBC
Louis Vachon, CEO, National Bank of Canada
Réjean Robitaille, CEO Laurentian Bank of Canada
Paulo Maia, CEO, HSBC of Canada
CC: The Honourable Joe Oliver, Minister of Finance
Dear CEOs,
On behalf of Citizen for Public Justice’s members across Canada, we want to express our appreciation for your recent voluntary decision to expand no-fee and low-cost bank accounts for low-income Canadians. We look forward to the implementation of this program and further encourage you to develop the program to include all low-income people, not just some.
CPJ is a national organization of members inspired by faith to work for justice in Canadian public policy. We encourage citizens, leaders in society and governments to support policies and practices which reflect God’s call for love, justice and stewardship. For this reason, we are heartened by actions of the for-profit sector that uphold corporate social responsibility.
Your recent announcement suggests that 7 million seniors and youth will have access to no-fee, low-cost bank accounts. Yet other figures alert us to the fact that approximately 90% of people living in poverty are not elderly[i]. Many individuals and families living in poverty do not receive the Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS), or are not students. These realities mean that many of our neighbours would not qualify for these accounts.
A great majority of the poor population could also use the $50 extra per year that those eligible will receive. Other government documentation of low-income such as proof of tax returns or provincial disability or welfare statements could be included as qualification for no-fee and low cost bank accounts.
We are encouraged by your commitment to deliver accessible services for those Canadians for whom every dollar counts. We believe that care for the poor and marginalized is a central calling of our faith, good government, and responsible individual and corporate citizenship. We respectfully ask you to widen the net of benefit to include the many more Canadians who are also low-income.
With appreciation and hope,
Will Postma Joe Gunn
Chair of the Board Executive Director
[i] Statistics Canada reported that, in 2011, 50% of poor households were non-elderly households and 40% were unattached individuals under the age of 65. The remaining 10% were elderly families and unattached individuals over the age of 65 (Statistics Canada, Table 202-0804 Persons in low income by economic family type, annual).